Just to add that the Form needs to be called up as well before it shows up in the Autocreate Form pane.
(Press F12 while the associated PAS unit it up on the editor).
Sounds like a bug. Did you add the file to your project for sure?
Check : Project -> Project Inspector
One more note about autocreating forms:
In a small project it is OK to autocreate all forms but not so in a big project.
Many forms are used only seldom. A form may not be needed at all during a user's work session.
Autocreating such forms slows down the startup and reserves memory.
Then it is better to create the form in code when needed and free it afterwards.
Juha